Skip to navigation Skip to content

Over $1 Million awarded for a survivor whose childhood abuse shaped a lifetime of harm

Over $1 Million awarded for a survivor whose childhood abuse shaped a lifetime of harm

A NSW District Court awarded our client $995,387 in damages after decades of psychological injury stemming from sexual assault at age six. We built a case that held the defendant fully accountable and delivered the recognition our client deserved.

Case: Brown vs Walker [2023] NSWDC 566

Court: NSW District Court

Jurisriction: Civil – Personal Injury

Decision Date: 15 December 2023

$995k total judgement awarded to our client

$349k general & aggravated damages, including 46 years of interest

$342k future economic loss & superannuation secured

$185k past economic loss recognised by the court

Decades of suffering, and a legal system that finally listened

Our client was six years old when she was sexually assaulted on four separate occasions by a 23-year-old neighbour on 23 December 1977. The matter was reported to the police at the time, and the defendant pleaded guilty and was sentenced for indecent assault.

The damage did not end there. The memories were repressed, surfacing only in 2019 after years of intensive psychotherapy. By the time our client came to us, she was 48, had been hospitalised for psychiatric treatment at least six times, had not worked full-time since 2018, and had been diagnosed with complex post-traumatic stress disorder and recurrent major depressive episodes. Her treating psychiatrist confirmed these conditions would require lifelong management.

“The abuse has caused her to have significant issues trusting men… caused a lot of confusion with regard to her sexual orientation… created a barrier to having children. She wanted to be a mother very much, and this remains one of the greatest disappointments of her life.” — Plaintiff’s evidence, as accepted by the Court

The case was filed in the Supreme Court, transferred to the District Court, and proceeded as an undefended assessment of damages after the defendant’s defence was struck out for non-compliance. Despite no opposition, the burden remained on our team at Wyatts to build a complete, credible evidentiary case, and the Court’s scrutiny was rigorous.

Our Approach

A complete evidentiary case, built with precision and argued with force

Cases involving historic sexual abuse and repressed memory require more than sympathy. They require ironclad evidence linking past trauma to present and future harm. We assembled a Court Book that left nothing to chance.

  • Secured a detailed medico-legal report from a leading forensic psychiatrist, establishing the clinical link between the 1977 assault and a lifetime of psychiatric illness
  • Subpoenaed and presented contemporaneous NSW Police records confirming the original complaint, the defendant’s admissions, and their conviction — providing an unassailable factual foundation
  • Obtained employment records and tax returns spanning 1997 to 2021 to quantify real, measurable income loss over two decades
  • Navigated the causation challenge head-on: where the psychiatrist estimated that domestic violence contributed roughly 50% to our client’s PTSD. We argued and the Court accepted a proportionate but still substantial damages award rather than a blanket reduction
  • Successfully argued for aggravated damages on the basis of the defendant’s conscious disregard for the rights of a six-year-old child, reflecting the particular gravity of his conduct

The Civil Liability Act 2002’s statutory caps did not apply because the defendant’s conduct constituted sexual assault under s.3B, damages were assessed at common law. This distinction matters, as it meant the Court could award full compensation without the constraints that apply to ordinary negligence claims.

The Result

Over $1 Million+ and the recognition our client never stopped deserving

The Honourable Waugh SC DCJ entered judgment for $995,000+ in full, with costs. The award covered every dimension of our client’s loss.

The Court accepted that the assault had a major adverse impact on every aspect of our client’s life, including her career, relationships, mental health, and ability to have children. Damages were awarded to reflect the full weight of that reality, even after applying the 50% causation discount recommended by the medical evidence.

$225,000 in general and aggravated damages,

Reflecting pain, suffering, loss of amenity, and the aggravated nature of the defendant’s conduct, plus $124,200 in interest accumulated over 46 years

$184,559 in past economic loss

Including a $50,000 buffer for reduced earning capacity throughout employment, and $121,225 for the five years of near-total incapacity following her resignation from Woolworths in 2018

$341,628 in future economic loss,

Based on projected lost earnings to retirement age at 67, reduced appropriately for the dual-causation finding and the vicissitudes of life

$80,000 in combined past and future out-of-pocket expenses,

Covering hospitalisation, psychiatric and psychological treatment costs spanning over a decade, and ongoing care needs confirmed by her treating team

Full costs order against the defendant

The defendant is legally required to pay for the plaintiff’s full legal costs in addition to the damages amount.

Our Statement

“An excellent outcome that reflects the hard work invested throughout the matter.” — Marcus Huston, Associate – Case Leader

We’re here to help

If you or someone you love has experienced sexual assault or abuse, it is never too late to seek justice. Our team has the experience, sensitivity, and tenacity to fight for the outcome you deserve. No win, no fee.

We are specialists in sexual abuse and assault claims, including workplace assault, family assault and physical assault.

Call our expert compensation lawyers today at 1800 773 880 to find out what you are entitled to.